I've been thinking about how, when someone claims to be a musician, we have no standardized scale by which to pinpoint exactly what kind of musician they are. This is not a full system yet, but I think it's a pretty good starting point.
The scoring should, of course, should be graduated. I play piano, bass, and drums. Piano is tough, and should certainly count for something. But bass... 4 strings, you play one at a time? That can't count as a whole instrument. And drums are tough to do really well, to lay down a groove or a pocket that just feels right. But to just play? I could teach you to play in 30 minutes. So, the first step is to identify which instrument(s) you play, and collect the points as listed below:
French horn: 10 points
Piano: 9 points
Oboe: 8 points
Guitar: 7 points
Cello: 6 points
Bass (fretless): 5 points
Saw: 4 points
Bass (fretted): 3 points
Drums: 2 points
Tambourine/shaker/spoons : 1 point
Then you multiply your score by 2 if you can sight read for that instrument, by 3 if you can improvise (in a way that sounds like music, not just in a "free-jazz odyssey" kind of way). Subtract 30 from your score if you also play, or have at any time played, accordion. Add back 15 if you write, and multiply by 3 if you write well (this is usually evidenced by the fact that people who don't actually know you are still interested in listening to your music).
Saturday, January 13, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
What's my score if I used to know how to play the trombone, trumpet, conga, piano and that cute little children's flute (I think it's called a "recorder" in English - pls someone explain that to me!)?
Olli
Let's see...
Piano: 9
Trombone: -3
Trumpet: 6
Congas: 1
Recorder: total /2
(9 -3 +6 +1) / 2 = 6.5.
Of course, you're a finance guy, so you get a multiplyer of 4 for choosing hobbies that don't involve a calculator. That brings you up to a very respectable 27 according to my calculations. Congratulations!
Post a Comment